Skip to main content
Copyright information guide

Copyright Objection meaning, the reply to a discrepancy letter and the hearing

A copyright objection is a challenge to an application for registration under Section 45 of the Copyright Act 1957. It takes two forms: an objection lodged by a third party within the 30-day window in Rule 70 of the Copyright Rules 2013, and a discrepancy letter in which the Copyright Office itself lists the defects found on scrutiny. Both are answered in writing, and the Registrar must hear the applicant before rejecting the application.

  • Law: Sections 44 to 50 and 72 of the Copyright Act 1957; Rule 70 of the Copyright Rules 2013
  • Authority: the Registrar of Copyrights at the Copyright Office, New Delhi, the single office for the whole country
  • Time limits: third-party objections within 30 days of the application (Rule 70(10)); discrepancy replies by the date in the letter, ordinarily 45 days
  • Who may act: the applicant signs the application (Rule 70(3)); an advocate or agent under a power of attorney may file, correspond and appear
For consultation No obligation, no lock-in

Request a Consultation

Share your details for a consultation on this topic

Confidential No obligation Consultation only
Reviewed by, Legal Expert
Harsh Jain
Last reviewed
15 Oct 2026
No service offered on this page
Information
Sources cited below
8 official
In short
Registration is optional under Section 45 and a certificate is only prima facie evidence (Section 48), but a filed application must pass two filters. For 30 days it is open to objection by anyone who claims an interest in the work (Rule 70(9) to (11)); if an objection arrives, the Registrar holds an inquiry and hears both sides. After the window closes the application is scrutinised, and defects are listed in a discrepancy letter that must be answered by the date it states. Rule 70(12) forbids rejection without a hearing, and Section 72 gives three months to appeal a rejection to the High Court.
  • Objection window30 days from receipt of the application by the Registrar (Rule 70(10))
  • Discrepancy letterReply by the date stated in the letter; the Copyright Office FAQ puts the period at ordinarily 45 days
  • HearingMandatory before any rejection (Rule 70(12)); notices and orders are published on the Copyright Office website
  • AppealTo the High Court within three months of the Registrar's order (Section 72)
Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Section 44 of the Copyright Act 1957 keeps a Register of Copyrights at the Copyright Office, and Section 45 lets the author, the publisher, the owner or any other person interested in the copyright apply on Form XIV, with the fee in the Second Schedule, to have the particulars of a work entered. Section 45(2) allows the Registrar to make the entry after such inquiry as the Registrar thinks fit. Rule 70 of the Copyright Rules 2013 turns that inquiry into a procedure: the applicant gives notice of the application to every person who claims an interest in the work or disputes the applicant's rights (Rule 70(9)); if no objection reaches the Registrar within 30 days of receipt of the application and the particulars appear correct, they are entered (Rule 70(10)); if an objection is received, or the Registrar is not satisfied about the particulars, the Registrar holds an inquiry and enters what the inquiry justifies (Rule 70(11)); and no application is rejected without an opportunity of hearing (Rule 70(12)).

In practice the Copyright Office publishes each new application on its website under waiting applications for objection, invites objections by post or online within 30 days, and lists any objected application with the date of objection. Once the window closes the examiners scrutinise the file. Where a document, a signature, a statement or a copy of the work is missing or inconsistent, the Office issues a discrepancy letter, posts it against the diary number under deficiency in applications and sets a date for the reply. Where the file is in order, the particulars are entered, the extract from the Register is signed under Rule 70(13) and the entry is published under Section 50A. On the status page an application therefore moves through received, waiting for objection, objected or discrepant, hearing, and registered or rejected.

Third-party objection

A rival claimant writes to the Registrar within the 30 days under Rule 70(10): a co-author left off the form, an employer or commissioning party claiming first ownership under Section 17, an assignee under Section 19, or the owner of an earlier work or trade mark. The Registrar hears both sides before deciding.

Discrepancy letter

The Office's own list of defects after scrutiny: a missing no-objection certificate from the author, incomplete statements of particulars, no copies or source code, no search certificate for a logo, or a wrong class of work. Answered by uploading the cure against the diary number by the date in the letter.

Hearing, rejection and appeal

Rule 70(12) requires a hearing before any rejection; notices and orders are published on the Copyright Office website. A rejection is a final order of the Registrar, appealable to the High Court within three months under Section 72, and the Register itself can be rectified by the High Court under Section 50.

Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Stages of a third-party objection
StageWhat happensProvision
Application filedForm XIV with the statement of particulars, the statement of further particulars for literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works, the fee and the copies of the work are filed, in person, by post or online. A diary number is allotted.Section 45(1); Rule 70(1), (2), (4) and (8)
Notice to interested personsThe applicant gives notice of the application to every person who claims or has any interest in the subject matter of the copyright or disputes the applicant's rights to it.Rule 70(9)
Objection windowThe application appears on the Copyright Office website under waiting applications for objection. Objections may be made in writing, by post or online, within 30 days of receipt of the application by the Registrar.Rule 70(10)
No objectionIf the Registrar is satisfied about the correctness of the particulars, they are entered in the Register of Copyrights.Rule 70(10)
Objection receivedThe Registrar holds such inquiry as the Registrar deems fit, gives notice to the applicant and the objector, takes their statements and documents and hears both parties, then enters such particulars as the Registrar considers necessary.Rule 70(11); Section 45(2)
RejectionPossible only after the applicant has been given an opportunity of hearing; the order is a final decision of the Registrar.Rule 70(12)
Completion and publicationRegistration is complete when a copy of the entries, signed by the Registrar or a Deputy Registrar, is issued; every entry, correction and rectification is published in the Official Gazette or as the Registrar directs, in practice in the Copyright Journal.Rule 70(13) and (14); Section 50A
Appeal and rectificationAny person aggrieved by a final decision of the Registrar may appeal to the High Court within three months; the Registrar or any person aggrieved may apply to the High Court to rectify the Register.Sections 72 and 50
Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

  • Signature and no-objection certificate. Rule 70(3) requires the application to be signed only by the applicant, who may be the author or the owner of the right; an owner who is not the author must enclose the author's original no-objection certificate. Letters frequently ask for the certificate, for a missing signature or for an assignment deed that explains the ownership claimed.
  • Statement of particulars. Name, address and nationality of the applicant and of every author, the nature of the applicant's interest, the class and title of the work, the language, whether it is published, and the year and country of first publication with the publisher's details. Inconsistencies between the form and the work are the most common discrepancy.
  • Copies of the work. Two copies of an unpublished work (Rule 70(4)); for a computer programme, at least the first ten and the last ten pages of source code, or the whole code if it is under 20 pages, with nothing blocked out (Rule 70(5) as amended in 2021).
  • Search certificate for a logo or label. An artistic work used or capable of being used in relation to goods or services needs a statement to that effect and a certificate from the Registrar of Trade Marks that no identical or deceptively similar trade mark is registered or applied for by anyone else (Section 45(1) proviso; Rule 70(6)). The certificate is obtained on Form TM-C from the Trade Marks Registry.
  • Design affidavit. An artistic work capable of registration under the Designs Act 2000 needs an affidavit that it has not been registered as a design and has not been applied to an article by an industrial process more than fifty times (Rule 70(7)).
  • Class of work. Literary, dramatic, musical, artistic, cinematograph film, sound recording or software: a work filed in the wrong class, or a single application covering more than one work, is returned for correction because Rule 70(2) allows one work per application.
  • Authority to act. Where an advocate or agent files and corresponds, the power of attorney executed by the applicant, so that the Office can deal with the representative.

The letter is issued through the applicant's e-filing account and by email, and is posted against the diary number under deficiency in copyright applications on the Copyright Office website. The reply is uploaded in the same place, with the corrected form or document and a covering letter that answers each point in order; where a fact is asserted, such as the date of creation or the circumstances of authorship, a short affidavit carries more weight than a bare statement. The Rules fix no period for the reply. The letter states the date, and the Copyright Office FAQ says the applicant is ordinarily given 45 days to remove a discrepancy. If no reply is received the application cannot proceed to registration; a rejection can follow only after the opportunity of hearing that Rule 70(12) requires, and hearing notices are published on the Office website.

Software, logos and product designs attract the most letters

Three categories account for a large share of discrepancy letters. Software applications are returned when the source code extract is incomplete or redacted, or when the form names a company as author although Section 2(d) treats the person who creates a computer-generated work, or the programmer, as author and the company as owner under Section 17. Logo and label applications are returned without the trade mark search certificate under Rule 70(6). Product-shaped artistic works are returned without the design affidavit under Rule 70(7), because Section 15 of the Act takes copyright away from a registrable design once it has been applied industrially more than fifty times.

Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

01

Notice of hearing

The Copyright Office fixes a date and issues a notice to the applicant and, in a third-party matter, to the objector. Notices are emailed and published under hearing notices and orders on the Office website against the diary number.

02

Written submissions

A concise statement of the applicant's case: the facts of creation, the chain of title, the answer to each objection or discrepancy, and the provisions relied on (Sections 13, 17 and 19 for ownership and originality, Section 45 and Rule 70 for the procedure). Documents are annexed and paginated.

03

Evidence of authorship and ownership

Dated drafts, source files with metadata, correspondence, publishing agreements, employment contracts or commissioning agreements, assignment deeds complying with Section 19 (in writing, signed, identifying the work, the rights, the duration and the territory), and the author's no-objection certificate.

04

Attendance

The applicant attends in person or through a pleader or agent holding a power of attorney; hearings are normally held by video conference. In a third-party objection both parties are heard under Rule 70(11), and each may answer the other's documents.

05

The order

The Registrar enters the particulars, enters them with modifications that the inquiry justifies, or rejects the application by a reasoned order. Orders are published alongside the hearing notices. Registration is complete when the signed extract from the Register issues under Rule 70(13).

06

Appeal or rectification

Section 72(1) allows any person aggrieved by a final decision of the Registrar to appeal to the High Court within three months, excluding the time taken to obtain a certified copy. After registration, the Registrar or any person aggrieved may apply to the High Court under Section 50 to add an omitted entry, expunge a wrong one or correct an error.

The Register is evidence, not title

Section 48 makes the Register prima facie evidence of the particulars entered in it, so a registration shifts the burden in a dispute but does not confer copyright. A court hearing an infringement suit under Section 55, or a rectification petition under Section 50, examines authorship and ownership afresh. An objector who loses before the Registrar keeps the right to sue, and an applicant who wins keeps only a rebuttable presumption.

Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Provisions most often engaged in a copyright objection
IssueProvisionRule applied
What is protectedSection 13Original literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works, cinematograph films and sound recordings. Computer programmes are literary works under Section 2(o). Originality requires skill and judgement of the author, not novelty.
Who is the authorSection 2(d)The writer, composer, artist, photographer, film producer, sound recording producer, or the person who causes a computer-generated work to be created.
Who is the first ownerSection 17The author, subject to exceptions: a work made in the course of employment under a contract of service belongs to the employer; photographs, paintings, portraits, engravings and films made for valuable consideration at another's instance belong to that person; Government and public undertaking works belong to the Government or undertaking.
How ownership is transferredSections 18 and 19Assignment must be in writing signed by the assignor, identify the work, specify the rights, the duration and the territorial extent and the royalty; if silent, the duration is five years and the territory is India (Section 19(5) and (6)).
Logos and labelsSection 45(1) proviso; Rule 70(6)An artistic work used in relation to goods or services needs the Registrar of Trade Marks' certificate that no identical or deceptively similar mark stands registered or applied for by another person.
Industrially applied designsSection 15; Rule 70(7)Copyright does not subsist in a design registered under the Designs Act 2000, and ceases in a registrable design reproduced industrially more than fifty times.
Correction of the RegisterSection 49; Rule 71The Registrar corrects clerical errors in names, addresses and particulars, on application or on the Registrar's own motion, after giving the affected person a chance to show cause.
Rectification of the RegisterSection 50The High Court, on the application of the Registrar or any person aggrieved, orders an omitted entry to be made, a wrong entry to be expunged or an error to be corrected.
Infringement and offenceSections 51, 55 and 63Civil remedies of injunction, damages and accounts; knowing infringement is an offence punishable with imprisonment of six months to three years and a fine.
Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Section 9 establishes the Copyright Office and Section 10 places it under the Registrar of Copyrights, who is appointed by the Central Government and assisted by Deputy Registrars. The Office works from Boudhik Sampada Bhawan, Dwarka, New Delhi, under the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks in the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade. It has no branch offices. Rule 70(8) allows an application to be filed in person, by post or through the online filing facility on the Office website, and the online route carries the fee payment, the statements of particulars, the copies of the work, the discrepancy correspondence and the hearing notices. Hearings are held by video conference.

Location returns only at the court stage. An appeal under Section 72 and a rectification petition under Section 50 go to the High Court; a suit for infringement under Section 62 may be filed in the district court within whose jurisdiction the plaintiff resides or carries on business, which the Act allows notwithstanding the ordinary rules on where a defendant must be sued.

  • Track application status. Searches by diary number and shows the stage: received, waiting for objection, objected, discrepant, hearing, registered or rejected.
  • Waiting applications for objection. The list of new applications open to objection, with the title and the applicant; objections go in by post or online within 30 days of the publication.
  • Objected application list. Applications against which an objection has been received, with the objection date and the document.
  • Deficiency in copyright applications. The discrepancy letters, searchable by diary number, and the upload point for the reply.
  • Hearing notices and orders. Dates of hearing and the Registrar's orders in objected and discrepant matters.
  • E-Register and Copyright Journal. The entries made under Section 45 and the publications required by Section 50A, by year.
Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Rule 70(3) requires every application to be signed only by the applicant, who may be the author or the owner of the right; a signature by an agent does not satisfy the rule, and an owner who is not the author must file the author's original no-objection certificate. Beyond the signature, an applicant may act through an advocate or another agent holding a power of attorney, which Form XIV provides for: the representative then files, receives the discrepancy letter and the hearing notice, replies and appears. The Copyright Office FAQ describes attendance at the hearing by the applicant or the applicant's pleader. The Advocates Act 1961 reserves the practice of law to enrolled advocates, so drafting a legal argument on ownership or originality for another person, and appearing in the High Court on appeal or rectification, is advocates' work; preparing the form and collecting documents on the applicant's instructions is not. Nothing in the Act or the Rules prevents an applicant from handling the entire procedure in person.

Related reading

Related topics

Diary number
The reference allotted to an application on filing, used for status tracking, discrepancy letters, objections, hearing notices and the final extract.
Form XIV
The application for registration of copyright under Rule 70(1), with its statement of particulars and, for literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works, the statement of further particulars.
Form XV
The application under Rule 70(1) for registration of changes in the particulars already entered in the Register, such as a change of owner after an assignment.
Waiting period
The 30 days from receipt of the application during which any person may object under Rule 70(10), while the application is listed on the Copyright Office website.
Discrepancy letter
The Copyright Office's communication after scrutiny listing the defects in an application and the date by which they must be removed; the Rules prescribe no period, and the Office FAQ states ordinarily 45 days.
Register of Copyrights
The register kept under Section 44 at the Copyright Office recording the titles of works and the names of authors, publishers and owners; prima facie evidence under Section 48.
Extract from the Register
The copy of the entries signed and issued under Rule 70(13), commonly called the registration certificate; registration is complete only when it issues.
Rectification
An order of the High Court under Section 50 adding an omitted entry, expunging a wrong one or correcting an error, on the application of the Registrar or any person aggrieved.
Related reading

Related topics

It is a challenge to an application for registration of copyright under Section 45 of the Copyright Act 1957. The term covers two different events: an objection lodged by a third party within 30 days of the application under Rule 70(10) of the Copyright Rules 2013, which leads to an inquiry and a hearing of both sides, and a discrepancy letter in which the Copyright Office lists defects found on scrutiny, which the applicant cures by the date stated. Neither is a rejection; Rule 70(12) requires a hearing before any application is rejected.
An objection comes from another person who claims an interest in the work or disputes the applicant's rights, within the 30-day window in Rule 70(10); the Registrar then holds an inquiry under Rule 70(11), hears both parties and decides whose particulars enter the Register. A discrepancy letter comes from the Copyright Office itself after scrutiny and lists missing or inconsistent items, such as the author's no-objection certificate, the source code extract or the trade mark search certificate. The reply to a letter is a cure of the file; the answer to an objection is a contest about ownership or originality.
Any person who claims or has an interest in the subject matter of the copyright or disputes the applicant's rights, to whom Rule 70(9) requires the applicant to give notice: co-authors, employers or commissioning parties claiming under Section 17, assignees under Section 19, owners of earlier works and owners of conflicting trade marks. The objection must reach the Registrar within 30 days of the receipt of the application (Rule 70(10)); the Copyright Office lists each new application on its website and accepts objections by post or online within that period.
The Copyright Rules 2013 prescribe no period. The letter itself states the date by which the discrepancy must be removed, and the Copyright Office FAQ says the applicant is ordinarily given 45 days. The reply is uploaded against the diary number under deficiency in copyright applications on the Office website. Where the reply does not cure the defect, or none is filed, the Office cannot register the work and must offer a hearing under Rule 70(12) before rejecting the application.
A missing or unsigned no-objection certificate from the author where the owner applies (Rule 70(3)); inconsistencies between the statement of particulars and the work, such as the author's name, the year of publication or the class of work; missing copies of an unpublished work (Rule 70(4)); an incomplete or redacted source code extract for software (Rule 70(5)); no trade mark search certificate for a logo or label used on goods or services (Rule 70(6)); no design affidavit for a product-shaped artistic work (Rule 70(7)); and a missing power of attorney where an agent files.
Yes. Rule 70(12) provides that the Registrar of Copyrights shall give an opportunity of hearing before rejecting any application for registration of any work. The Copyright Office publishes hearing notices and the resulting orders on its website against the diary number, and the applicant attends in person or through a pleader or agent, normally by video conference. In a third-party objection both the applicant and the objector are heard under Rule 70(11).
Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

FROM THE PROTAX LIBRARY

Recent Articles & Guides

Practical reading on business records, tax filings and the decisions that come with running a company.

Newsletter

Stay ahead on compliance, tax & business updates

Get selected business and compliance updates by email. Once a month, no spam.

  • 100% privacy
  • 1 email / month
  • Unsubscribe anytime
Contact ProTax
Chosen by individuals and businesses

Get Help With Your Business

Tell us what you need help with. Our team will review your enquiry and explain the next steps.

Free Consultation No Obligations Expert Advice
For consultation No obligation, no lock-in

Send a Consultation Request

Share your details for a consultation on this topic

Confidential No obligation Consultation only
For consultation No obligation, no lock-in

Consultation Request

Share your details for a consultation on this topic

Confidential No obligation Consultation only