Skip to main content
Design information guide

Design Objection grounds, the reply to the examination report and the time limits

A design objection is the written statement of objections the Controller of Designs issues under Rule 18 of the Designs Rules 2001 after examining an application under Section 5 of the Designs Act 2000. It says why the design cannot yet be registered: lack of novelty, prior publication, a design outside Section 2(d), or a defective representation or class. The applicant has three months to answer or to ask for a hearing.

  • Law: Designs Act 2000; Designs Rules 2001 as amended in 2008, 2014 and 2021
  • Authority: the Controller of Designs at the Patent Office, Kolkata; applications are received at all four patent offices and online
  • Time limit: reply or hearing request within three months of the statement of objections; objections removed within six months of filing, extendable by three on Form 18 (Rule 18)
  • Who may act: the applicant, a legal practitioner or a registered patent agent authorised on Form 21 (Section 43, Rule 9)
For consultation No obligation, no lock-in

Request a Consultation

Share your details for a consultation on this topic

Confidential No obligation Consultation only
Reviewed by, Legal Expert
Harsh Jain
Last reviewed
15 Oct 2026
No service offered on this page
Information
Sources cited below
8 official
In short
An objection is a provisional view, not a refusal. Rule 17 lets the Controller accept an application only when the examiner's report shows no lawful objection, so a report with objections leads to a written statement under Rule 18 and a dialogue with the applicant. Most objections fall into three groups: the design is not new or original or was published before (Section 4), the subject matter is not a design (Section 2(d)), or the papers are defective. Each has its own answer; the applicant may be heard before any refusal, and a refusal is appealable to the High Court.
  • Reply windowThree months from the communication of the objections (Rule 18(1))
  • Outer limitSix months from the filing date, extendable by three months on Form 18 (provisos to Rule 18(1))
  • HearingOn request within the three months, with at least ten days' notice (Rule 18(2) and (3))
  • AppealTo the High Court within three months of the Controller's order (Sections 5(4) and 36)
Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

An application on Form 1 asks the Controller to register a design for an article in one class of the Locarno Classification. Under Section 5(1) the Controller refers it to an examiner, who checks that the subject matter is a design within Section 2(d), that it is new or original and has not been published anywhere before the filing or priority date (Section 4), that the representations and the class are in order, and that nothing else in the Act or the Rules bars registration. Where the report finds an objection or calls for an amendment, Rule 18(1) requires a statement of the objections to be sent in writing to the applicant or the agent. On the e-filing portal the application then shows as objected, and the clock in Rule 18 starts.

The statement is not a decision. Rule 18(5) lets the Controller register or refuse only after the applicant has answered, or has had the chance to be heard, or has let the period pass. Section 5(4) adds that any person aggrieved by a refusal may appeal to the High Court. The objection stage is therefore the only point in the design procedure at which the applicant and the Office argue the merits: there is no publication of the application before registration and no opposition by third parties, who must wait for registration and then petition for cancellation under Section 19.

Formal objections

Representations that do not show the article from every required view (Rule 14), a missing statement of novelty where the Controller asks for one (Rule 12), the wrong class or more than one class (Section 5(3)), no Form 21 for the agent, or no address for service in India (Rule 4). Cured by filing the document or the corrected representations.

Substantive objections

The examiner cites an earlier registration, a catalogue, a website or a prior sale and says the design is not new or original, was published before the filing date, or is not significantly distinguishable from known designs (Section 4(a) to (c)). Answered by comparison and argument, or by amending the design within its identity.

Definitional objections

The features claimed are dictated by function, amount to a mode or principle of construction or a mere mechanical device, or the subject is a trade mark, a property mark or an artistic work, all of which Section 2(d) excludes. Answered by showing the features appeal to and are judged by the eye, or by disclaiming the excluded matter.

Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Objection grounds and the answers the Act allows
GroundProvisionWhat answers it
Not new or originalSection 4(a); Section 2(g)Showing the design originates from its author and differs, in the eye of the customer, from the designs cited; an old design newly applied to a different article can be original under Section 2(g).
Disclosed to the public before the filing or priority date, in India or abroad, by publication in tangible form, by use or in any other waySection 4(b)Showing the cited document is later than the filing date, is not a publication in tangible form, or shows a different design; relying on Section 21 where the disclosure was at a notified exhibition and notice on Form 9 was given beforehand.
Not significantly distinguishable from known designs or a combination of known designsSection 4(c)A feature-by-feature comparison, placed side by side, showing that the overall visual impression differs; trade evidence of how customers see the article.
Scandalous or obscene matterSection 4(d)Rare. The matter is removed from the design or the application is withdrawn.
Not a design: a mode or principle of construction, or in substance a mere mechanical deviceSection 2(d)Showing that the shape or configuration has visual features not dictated solely by the function the article performs; disclaiming functional elements in the statement of novelty.
Subject matter is a trade mark, a property mark or an artistic workSection 2(d), read with Section 2(c) of the Copyright Act 1957Showing the features are applied to an article by an industrial process and are not merely a logo or a drawing. An artistic work that has been industrially applied loses copyright instead (Section 15 of the Copyright Act 1957).
Application covers more than one class, or the wrong classSection 5(3); Rule 10Amending to the correct Locarno class, or filing a separate application for each class. The Controller decides a doubtful classification in consultation with the applicant.
Representations or statement of novelty defectiveRules 11, 12 and 14Filing corrected representations that show the design clearly from the required views, with the statement of novelty endorsed where the Controller requires it.
Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Periods in the objection procedure
EventPeriodProvision
Statement of objections communicatedStarts the reply periodRule 18(1): sent in writing to the applicant or the agent
Reply, or request for a hearingWithin three months of the communicationRule 18(1): otherwise the applicant is deemed to have withdrawn the application
Objections finally removedNot later than six months from the date of filing the applicationFirst proviso to Rule 18(1)
Extension of that periodUp to three further months, on Form 18 with the fee, applied for before the six months endSecond proviso to Rule 18(1)
Completion of the applicationSix months from the date of application, extendable by three months on Form 18Rule 21; Section 5(5) deems an incomplete application abandoned
Notice of hearingAt least ten days, or shorter notice where reasonable in the circumstancesRule 18(3)
Appeal against a refusalWithin three months of the Controller's order, excluding the time taken to obtain a copySections 5(4) and 36

Two clocks run at once

The three months in Rule 18(1) run from the date the statement of objections is communicated, but the proviso caps the whole exercise at six months from the filing date, extendable once by three months on Form 18 filed before the six months expire. An examination report issued late in the life of the application therefore leaves less than three months, and an extension request made after the six-month point is too late. The e-filing portal records both dates; the safe course is to reply early and to file Form 18 as soon as it is clear that more time is needed.

Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

01

Read the statement of objections against the Act

Identify each objection and its legal basis: Section 4 novelty or prior publication, the Section 2(d) definition, Section 5(3) class, or a formality under Rules 11 to 14. Note the communication date, from which the three months in Rule 18(1) run, and the filing date, from which the six-month cap runs.

02

Study the cited prior art

Obtain the cited registrations from the design search portal and the cited publications in full. Check their dates against the filing or priority date, the article they relate to and the features actually visible. A citation that post-dates the application or shows a different overall impression is answered on that ground alone.

03

Choose the response for each objection

Argument with a visual comparison; amended representations that clarify the design without changing its identity; a statement of novelty under Rule 12 confining the claim to the new features and disclaiming functional or excluded matter; a change of class; or, where the objection is sound, withdrawal and a redesign.

04

Prepare the documents

A written reply addressing every objection in order, comparison sheets placing the design beside each citation, amended representations in the prescribed form (Rule 14), an affidavit where facts such as the date of first disclosure are asserted, Form 21 if an agent acts and Form 18 if an extension is needed.

05

File within the period

Upload the reply and annexures against the application number on the e-filing portal, or file them at the Patent Office under Rule 3, within three months of the communication and within the six-month cap. Keep the acknowledgement.

06

Ask for a hearing where needed

Rule 18(2) fixes a hearing where the applicant applies for one within the three months, or where the Controller considers it desirable. The notice gives at least ten days (Rule 18(3)); the applicant confirms attendance, and the hearing is held by telephone or video conference, followed by detailed written submissions (Rule 18(4)).

07

Receive the decision

After the hearing, or without one where the applicant did not attend, the Controller registers the design or refuses the application under Rule 18(5). Registration leads to a certificate under Section 9 and publication under Section 7; a refusal is appealable under Sections 5(4) and 36.

The statement of novelty does most of the work

Rule 12 lets the applicant, and obliges the applicant when the Controller asks, to endorse on the application and on each representation a brief statement of the novelty claimed. A statement that confines the claim to the shape and configuration of the article as shown, and disclaims any trade mark, word, letter or numeral appearing in the representations, removes two of the most frequent objections without touching the design itself.

Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Outcomes after the response
OutcomeProvisionWhat follows
RegisteredRule 18(5); Sections 7 and 9A certificate of registration issues and the particulars are published. The registration takes effect from the filing date (Section 5(6)); copyright in the design runs ten years from that date and is extended by five years on an application on Form 3 made before expiry (Section 11).
Refused, after a hearing or on the recordRule 18(5); Section 5(4)An appeal lies to the High Court within three months of the order (Section 36). The High Court may take the assistance of an expert, and its decision is final.
Deemed withdrawnRule 18(1)No reply and no hearing request within three months of the communication. Because applications are not published before registration, a fresh application remains possible if the design has not meanwhile been disclosed to the public.
Deemed abandonedRule 21; Section 5(5)The application was not completed within six months of filing, or the extended period, through the applicant's default. The consequence is the same as withdrawal.

A registered design that lapses because the Section 11 extension was not sought in time can be restored on an application under Section 12 made within one year of the date on which it ceased, on Form 4, if the failure was unintentional. Registration is also the moment the design becomes vulnerable to third parties: the particulars are published, the register is open to inspection, and any person interested may petition for cancellation under Section 19 on the same grounds the examiner could have raised, so a registration obtained by overcoming a weak objection can still be tested later.

Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Examination objection and cancellation petition compared
AspectExamination objection (Rule 18)Cancellation petition (Section 19)
Who raises itThe Controller, on the examiner's report under Section 5(1)Any person interested, on Form 8 with a statement of the grounds (Rule 29)
WhenBefore registration, within the Rule 18 and Rule 21 periodsAt any time after registration, during the term of the design
GroundsAny ground on which registration may be refused: Sections 2(d), 4 and 5(3) and the RulesThe five grounds in Section 19(1): prior registration in India, prior publication in India or abroad, not new or original, not registrable under the Act, not a design under Section 2(d)
ProcedureWritten reply, optional hearing on ten days' notice, decision under Rule 18(5)Counter-statement by the proprietor, ordinarily within one month and extendable to three in total; affidavit evidence in turn; hearing on ten days' notice, with Form 20 to signal attendance (Rule 29)
Decision and appealRegistration or refusal; appeal to the High Court within three months (Sections 5(4) and 36)Cancellation or dismissal; appeal to the High Court, and the Controller may refer the petition to the High Court (Section 19(2))
Also available as a defenceNot applicableEvery Section 19 ground is a defence in a piracy suit under Section 22(3); the suit is then transferred to the High Court (Section 22(4))

Because applications are kept from the public until registration, a competitor learns of a design only when the particulars appear under Section 7, and the remedies are the cancellation petition or the defence in a piracy suit. Section 22 gives the registered proprietor two remedies against a person who, without licence or written consent, applies the design or a fraudulent or obvious imitation to an article in the registered class for sale, imports such articles for sale, or knowingly publishes or exposes them for sale: a fixed sum for each contravention recoverable as a contract debt, subject to a ceiling for any one design, or a suit for damages and an injunction. Such a suit cannot be filed in a court below that of a District Judge, and once the defendant pleads a Section 19 ground the case moves to the High Court.

Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

Under Section 43(1) an application or communication to the Controller may be signed by, and attendance before the Controller made by or through, a legal practitioner or an agent whose name is entered in the register of patent agents kept under Section 125 of the Patents Act 1970. Rule 9 requires the authority to be given under the applicant's own signature, on Form 21, after which the agent receives every notice, requisition and communication. The applicant may always act in person. Section 43(2) lets the Controller insist that an agent be resident in India and that a person who does not reside in India employ one, which is how foreign applicants prosecute their applications, and Rule 4 requires every applicant to give an address for service in India, to which the statement of objections is sent.

Applications and later documents may be left at the Patent Office, Kolkata, or at the branch offices at Delhi, Mumbai and Chennai, by hand, post, courier, fax or email and through the e-filing portal (Rule 3). A branch office transmits what it receives to the head office at Kolkata (Rule 3(4)), whose Designs Wing examines the application, issues the statement of objections and conducts the hearing, normally by video conference. The office with jurisdiction over an application follows the applicant's principal place of business or address for service, as the jurisdiction page of the Office sets out, but the file itself is prosecuted at Kolkata wherever it was filed.

Related reading

Related topics

Design
Features of shape, configuration, pattern, ornament or composition of lines or colours applied to an article by an industrial process and judged solely by the eye (Section 2(d)); the definition excludes modes of construction, mechanical devices, trade marks, property marks and artistic works.
Article
Any article of manufacture, and any substance that is artificial or partly artificial and partly natural, including a part made and sold separately (Section 2(a)). A design is registered for an article in a class.
Original
Originating from the author of the design, including an old design that is new in its application to an article (Section 2(g)).
Representation
The drawings or photographs of the article filed with Form 1 showing the design from the required views (Rules 11 and 14). The registration protects what the representations show.
Statement of novelty
The endorsement under Rule 12 on the application and the representations stating the features in which novelty is claimed and disclaiming matter such as words, letters or trade marks.
Locarno Classification
The international classification of industrial designs published by WIPO, adopted by Rule 10 and the Third Schedule as amended in 2021. An application may be made in one class only (Section 5(3)).
Statement of objections
The Controller's written communication under Rule 18(1) after examination, which the applicant must answer, or meet with a request for a hearing, within three months.
Piracy of a registered design
Applying the design, or a fraudulent or obvious imitation of it, to articles in the registered class for sale without licence, importing such articles for sale, or knowingly selling or exposing them for sale (Section 22).
Related reading

Related topics

It is the statement of objections the Controller of Designs sends under Rule 18(1) of the Designs Rules 2001 after the examination required by Section 5(1) of the Designs Act 2000. The statement says why the design cannot yet be registered: it is not new or original or was published before the filing date (Section 4), it is not a design within Section 2(d), it is in the wrong class (Section 5(3)), or the representations or other papers are defective. The applicant must remove the objection or ask for a hearing within three months.
No. The statement of objections is the examiner's provisional view communicated by the Controller. Rule 18(5) allows the Controller to register or refuse only after the applicant has replied, or has been offered a hearing, or has let the period pass. A refusal is a reasoned order, and Section 5(4) read with Section 36 gives the applicant three months to appeal to the High Court. Most objections end in registration once the representations are amended or the novelty is explained.
Rule 18(1) gives three months from the date the statement of objections is communicated to remove the objection or apply for a hearing, failing which the application is deemed withdrawn. The first proviso caps the period for removing objections at six months from the date of filing, and the second proviso allows one extension of up to three months on Form 18, applied for before the six months end. Rule 21 separately requires the application to be completed within six months of filing, extendable by three on Form 18.
Lack of novelty or originality and prior publication under Section 4(a) and (b), usually supported by a cited earlier registration or an online listing; the design being not significantly distinguishable from known designs under Section 4(c); features dictated by function or amounting to a mere mechanical device, which Section 2(d) excludes; the presence of a trade mark, word or logo in the representations; an application covering more than one class, contrary to Section 5(3); and representations that do not show the article from the required views (Rule 14).
Yes. Section 4(b) bars a design disclosed to the public anywhere in India or abroad by publication in tangible form, by use or in any other way before the filing or priority date, and the applicant's own catalogue, website listing or sale is a disclosure. The exceptions are narrow: Section 21 protects display at an exhibition notified by the Central Government if notice on Form 9 was given before exhibiting and the application follows within six months, and Section 44 preserves a foreign filing date for an Indian application made within six months.
Yes, within its identity. Rule 18(1) contemplates objections that require amendment, and the usual amendments are corrected representations showing the article from the required views, a statement of novelty under Rule 12 confining the claim to the features in which novelty lies, a disclaimer of words, letters, numerals or trade marks appearing in the representations, and a change to the correct class. An amendment that turns the design into a different one is not accepted; a new design needs a fresh application with a new filing date.
Related reading

Related topics

The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.

FROM THE PROTAX LIBRARY

Recent Articles & Guides

Practical reading on business records, tax filings and the decisions that come with running a company.

Newsletter

Stay ahead on compliance, tax & business updates

Get selected business and compliance updates by email. Once a month, no spam.

  • 100% privacy
  • 1 email / month
  • Unsubscribe anytime
Contact ProTax
Chosen by individuals and businesses

Get Help With Your Business

Tell us what you need help with. Our team will review your enquiry and explain the next steps.

Free Consultation No Obligations Expert Advice
For consultation No obligation, no lock-in

Send a Consultation Request

Share your details for a consultation on this topic

Confidential No obligation Consultation only
For consultation No obligation, no lock-in

Consultation Request

Share your details for a consultation on this topic

Confidential No obligation Consultation only