- AppointmentSection 139(1): at the AGM for five years; ADT-1 within 15 days
- ReportSection 143: opinion to the members, plus CARO 2020 where applicable
- IndependenceSection 141 disqualifications; Section 144 prohibited services
- FilingSection 137: AOC-4 within 30 days of the AGM
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
The audit exists for the people who cannot inspect the books themselves: shareholders, lenders, the Registrar and the public. Section 129 requires the financial statements to give a true and fair view in the form set out in Schedule III and to comply with the accounting standards notified under Section 133. The auditor tests whether that has been done, using the Standards on Auditing that Section 143(10) makes binding, and says so in a report that is attached to the statements, read at the meeting and filed with the Registrar.
The auditor does not prepare the accounts. Preparation, the Board's report and the signing of the statements under Section 134 are the directors' responsibility, and Section 144 forbids the auditor from keeping the books of the company being audited. What the auditor supplies is an opinion backed by evidence: confirmations from banks and debtors, physical verification of stock and assets, tests of internal controls, and scrutiny of the judgments behind provisions, revenue recognition and related-party transactions.
Unmodified opinion
The statements give a true and fair view and comply with the Act. The common outcome.
Qualified opinion
True and fair "except for" a stated matter, such as an unconfirmed balance or a departure from a standard.
Adverse opinion
The misstatements are so material and pervasive that the statements do not give a true and fair view.
Disclaimer
The auditor could not obtain enough evidence to form any opinion, for instance where records were lost.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
| Entity | Provision | Requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Private limited, public limited and one person company | Sections 139 and 143, Companies Act 2013 | Audit every financial year from incorporation. No exemption for small companies, dormant companies or companies without revenue. |
| Section 8 (not-for-profit) company | Sections 139 and 143; paragraph 1(2) of CARO 2020 | Audited like any other company; exempt only from the CARO 2020 statement. |
| Government company | Sections 139(5), 139(7) and 143(5) to (7) | Auditor appointed by the Comptroller and Auditor-General, who may issue directions and conduct a supplementary audit. |
| Limited liability partnership | Section 34(4), LLP Act 2008; Rule 24(8), LLP Rules 2009 | Audit only where turnover or partners' contribution exceeds the limit the Rule sets; smaller LLPs may opt in voluntarily. Audited accounts go in Form 8. |
| Partnership firm and sole proprietorship | No audit under their own law | Audited only under Section 44AB of the Income-tax Act 1961 when turnover or receipts cross its limits, or under a lender's or regulator's requirement. |
| Branch of a company, in India or abroad | Section 143(8) | Audited by the company's auditor or by a qualified branch auditor, whose report is forwarded to the company's auditor. |
Financial year and meeting
The financial year of a company ends on 31 March (Section 2(41)), the annual general meeting must be held within six months of that date (Section 96), and the audited statements are laid at that meeting (Section 129(2)). The audit therefore has a hard calendar: the auditor's report is dated after the Board approves the statements under Section 134 and before the meeting notice goes out.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
| Event | Provision | Form and time limit |
|---|---|---|
| First auditor of a new company | Section 139(6) | Appointed by the Board within 30 days of registration; failing that, by the members at an extraordinary general meeting within 90 days. Holds office until the first annual general meeting. |
| Appointment at the annual general meeting | Section 139(1); Rule 4 | For a term from the conclusion of that meeting to the conclusion of the sixth meeting after it, with the auditor's written consent and eligibility certificate taken first. Notice to the Registrar in ADT-1 within 15 days of the meeting. Annual ratification was removed in 2018. |
| Rotation | Section 139(2); Rules 5 and 6 | Listed companies and the classes Rule 5 prescribes by paid-up capital and borrowings (excluding one person and small companies): an individual for one term of five years, a firm for two consecutive terms, then a cooling-off of five years during which no firm with a common partner or network may be appointed. |
| Casual vacancy | Section 139(8) | Filled by the Board within 30 days. Where the vacancy follows a resignation, the appointment must also be approved by the members at a general meeting within three months of the Board's recommendation. |
| Resignation | Section 140(2) and (3); Rule 8 | The resigning auditor files ADT-3 with the company and the Registrar within 30 days, stating the reasons and relevant facts. Failure attracts the penalty in Section 140(3). |
| Removal before the term ends | Section 140(1); Rule 7 | Only by special resolution after the previous approval of the Central Government (Regional Director) on an application in ADT-2 made within 30 days of the Board resolution; the meeting is held within 60 days of the approval. The auditor is heard before removal. |
| Not reappointing a retiring auditor | Section 140(4) | Special notice of the resolution; the retiring auditor may make a written representation that is circulated to members and read at the meeting. |
| Removal by the Tribunal | Section 140(5) | On an application by the Central Government or any person concerned, where the auditor acted fraudulently or colluded in fraud. The auditor is barred from appointment in any company for five years and faces Section 447. |
Eligibility is governed by Section 141. Only a person qualified as the section requires may be appointed: in practice a holder of a certificate of practice from the statutory accountancy institute, acting alone or through a firm in which the majority of partners practising in India hold that qualification. A limited liability partnership may be appointed as a firm, and only its qualified partners sign on its behalf. Section 141(3) then lists who is disqualified even though qualified, and Section 141(4) vacates the office automatically if a disqualification arises after appointment.
- Body corporate. A company cannot be an auditor; a limited liability partnership registered under the LLP Act 2008 can (Section 141(3)(a)).
- Officer or employee of the company, or a partner or employee of such a person (Section 141(3)(b) and (c)).
- Financial interest. A person, or a relative or partner, holding any security or interest in the company or its holding, subsidiary or associate, beyond the small relative holding Rule 10 permits; a person indebted to the company, or for whose debt the company has given a guarantee, beyond the prescribed sum (Section 141(3)(d)).
- Business relationship with the company or its group, other than arm's-length transactions in the ordinary course of business that Rule 10 excludes (Section 141(3)(e)).
- Relative who is a director or key managerial person of the company (Section 141(3)(f)).
- Ceiling on audits. A person in full-time employment elsewhere, or a person already auditing more than twenty companies, counting each partner of a firm separately and excluding the small, dormant and one person companies the clause carves out (Section 141(3)(g)).
- Conviction for an offence involving fraud within the previous ten years (Section 141(3)(h)).
- Prohibited services. A person whose firm or network provides any Section 144 service to the company on the date of appointment (Section 141(3)(i)).
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
Engagement and independence
The auditor confirms eligibility under Section 141, gives the written consent and certificate Rule 4 requires, and records the terms of engagement. Where an audit committee exists under Section 177, it recommends the appointment and the remuneration that Section 142 leaves to the members.
Planning and risk assessment
The auditor studies the business, identifies the accounts and disclosures where misstatement is most likely, sets materiality and decides how much reliance to place on internal controls. Related parties, revenue, inventory and going concern are standard risk areas.
Testing internal financial controls
For companies within Section 143(3)(i), the auditor tests whether controls over financial reporting exist and operate, because the report must state an opinion on them. Smaller private companies are exempted by the notification of 13 June 2017.
Substantive procedures
Confirmations from banks, lenders, debtors and creditors; attendance at stock counts; vouching of transactions; recomputation of depreciation, interest and tax; reading of minutes, contracts and statutory registers; analytical review of ratios and trends.
Communication with the Board
Significant findings, control weaknesses and proposed adjustments are discussed with management and reported to those charged with governance. Suspected fraud triggers the separate Section 143(12) procedure.
Approval, report and meeting
The Board approves the statements and the directors sign them under Section 134, after which the auditor signs the report under Section 145 with the CARO 2020 statement annexed. The statements and report are circulated with the notice of the annual general meeting (Section 136) and laid at it.
Filing with the Registrar
AOC-4 (or AOC-4 XBRL, AOC-4 CFS or AOC-4 NBFC as applicable) with the audited statements, the Board's report and the auditor's report within 30 days of the meeting under Section 137, and the annual return in MGT-7 or MGT-7A within 60 days under Section 92.
Fraud reporting under Section 143(12)
An auditor who, in the course of the audit, has reason to believe that an offence of fraud is being or has been committed against the company by its officers or employees must act under Rule 13 of the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules 2014. Where the amount involved reaches the limit the Rule prescribes, the auditor reports to the Board or audit committee within two days, allows 45 days for a reply, and then forwards the report with the reply to the Central Government in Form ADT-4 within 15 days. Smaller frauds are reported to the audit committee or Board and disclosed in the Board's report. Section 143(13) protects a report made in good faith, and Section 143(15) penalises an auditor who fails to report.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
| Element | Provision | What the auditor states |
|---|---|---|
| Opinion | Section 143(2) | Whether the financial statements give a true and fair view of the state of affairs, the profit or loss and the cash flows, and comply with the Act. |
| Statutory matters | Section 143(3)(a) to (h) | Whether all information and explanations were obtained, proper books kept, branch reports received, the statements agree with the books and comply with accounting standards, any director is disqualified under Section 164(2), and any qualification on the books. |
| Internal financial controls | Section 143(3)(i) | Whether the company has adequate internal financial controls with reference to financial statements and whether they operate effectively; exempted for the private companies the 2017 notification describes. |
| Rule 11 matters | Rule 11, Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules 2014 | Pending litigations disclosed, provision for foreseeable losses on long-term contracts, transfers to the Investor Education and Protection Fund, funds routed through intermediaries, compliance of dividends with Section 123, and, from the financial year 2023-24, whether the accounting software kept an audit trail throughout the year. |
| CARO 2020 statement | Section 143(11); the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order 2020 | Twenty-one clauses on fixed assets, inventory, loans and investments, deposits, cost records, statutory dues, defaults to lenders, use of borrowings, fraud, related parties, internal audit, registration with the Reserve Bank, cash losses, auditor resignations, going concern ratios, corporate social responsibility and qualifications in group companies. |
| Government company directions | Section 143(5) | Answers to the directions issued by the Comptroller and Auditor-General, who may then conduct a supplementary audit under Section 143(6). |
CARO 2020 applies to every company including a foreign company, with exceptions listed in paragraph 1(2): banking companies, insurance companies, Section 8 companies, one person companies, small companies and private companies that stay within the Order's limits on paid-up capital and reserves, borrowings and revenue. The exemptions turn on the position in the financial year under audit, so a private company can move in and out of the Order from one year to the next. Where the Order applies, the auditor of a holding company must also report qualifications and adverse remarks made in the CARO statements of the companies included in its consolidated statements (clause (xxi)).
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
- Accounting and book keeping services (Section 144(a)).
- Internal audit (Section 144(b)), which is why the internal auditor under Section 138 is always a different person.
- Design and implementation of any financial information system (Section 144(c)).
- Actuarial services (Section 144(d)).
- Investment advisory and investment banking services (Section 144(e) and (f)).
- Outsourced financial services and management services (Section 144(g) and (h)), the two widest heads.
- Other services the Central Government prescribes (Section 144(i)); none have been added so far.
- Permitted work. Tax audit under Section 44AB, certification, and services the Board or audit committee approves that fall outside the list.
Section 147 sets the penalties. A company that contravenes Sections 139 to 146 is fined within the range the section fixes, and every officer in default is fined. An auditor who contravenes Sections 139, 144 or 145 is fined; where the contravention is knowing or wilful with intent to deceive the company, its shareholders, creditors or tax authorities, the auditor faces imprisonment of up to one year as well as a fine. A convicted auditor must refund the remuneration received and pay damages to the company, statutory bodies or any person who relied on the report (Section 147(3)); where a firm's partners acted in concert in a fraud, the firm and the partners are jointly and severally liable (Section 147(5)).
The National Financial Reporting Authority
Section 132 constitutes the National Financial Reporting Authority to recommend accounting and auditing standards, monitor compliance and oversee the quality of audits of the classes of companies the NFRA Rules 2018 bring within its reach: listed companies, large unlisted public companies, insurance, banking and electricity companies, and bodies the Central Government refers. The Authority may investigate professional misconduct, impose monetary penalties measured as multiples of the fees received, and debar an auditor or firm from practice for six months to ten years. Its orders are appealable to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
| Audit | Law and trigger | Appointed by, reports to, output |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory audit | Sections 139 to 147, Companies Act 2013; every company, every year | Members (Board for the first auditor); report to the members under Section 143; filed with AOC-4. |
| Tax audit | Section 44AB, Income-tax Act 1961; turnover or receipts above the limits, or exit from a presumptive scheme | The taxpayer; an accountant under Section 288; Form 3CA or 3CB with Form 3CD on the income-tax e-filing portal, due one month before the return. |
| Internal audit | Section 138, Companies Act 2013; Rule 13, Companies (Accounts) Rules 2014: listed companies and the unlisted and private companies above the Rule's capital, turnover, borrowing or deposit limits | The Board; a professional the Board chooses, who may be an employee; reports to the audit committee or Board; not filed. |
| Cost audit | Section 148, Companies Act 2013; the Companies (Cost Records and Audit) Rules 2014: specified industries above turnover limits | The Board, notified in CRA-2; a practising member of the statutory cost accountancy institute; report in CRA-3 within 180 days of the year end, filed by the company in CRA-4 within 30 days. |
Related topics
- True and fair view
- The standard in Sections 129 and 143(2): the statements, prepared under Schedule III and the notified accounting standards, present the company's position and performance without material misstatement.
- Standards on Auditing
- The auditing standards that Section 143(9) requires every auditor to follow, notified under Section 143(10); they govern planning, evidence, documentation and the form of the report.
- CARO 2020
- The Companies (Auditor's Report) Order 2020 issued under Section 143(11), a 21-clause statement annexed to the audit report of every company the Order covers.
- Internal financial controls
- The policies and procedures a company adopts for orderly and efficient business, safeguarding of assets, prevention of fraud and reliable financial reporting (Explanation to Section 134(5)); reported on under Section 143(3)(i).
- Key audit matters
- The matters that, in the auditor's judgment, were of most significance in the audit, described in the report of a listed company under the relevant Standard on Auditing.
- Casual vacancy
- A vacancy in the office of auditor arising before the term ends, by resignation, death or disqualification, filled under Section 139(8).
- Audit trail
- The edit log an accounting software must keep for every transaction, required of every company by the Companies (Accounts) Rules 2014 from 1 April 2023 and reported on under Rule 11(g).
- Supplementary audit
- The further audit the Comptroller and Auditor-General may conduct of a government company under Section 143(6), with comments that are placed before the meeting.
Related topics
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
- Companies Act, 2013 (Sections 139 to 148), India Code
- Companies Act 2013 and amendments, Ministry of Corporate Affairs
- Companies Rules, including the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules 2014, MCA e-book
- National Financial Reporting Authority
- Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008 and LLP Rules 2009, India Code
- MCA portal (ADT-1, ADT-3, AOC-4 and MGT-7 e-forms)
- Income-tax Act, 1961 (Section 44AB, tax audit), Income Tax Department
