- ArticlesAltered by special resolution under Section 14; entrenchment under Section 5(3) protects investor clauses from a later majority
- TransfersA private company's Articles must restrict transfer (Section 2(68)); contracts on transfer are enforceable between the parties (Section 58(2) proviso)
- Foreign investorsOptions exit at fair value after a one-year lock-in, with no assured return (NDI Rules 2019)
- DisputesContract claims go to arbitration; oppression petitions under Section 241 need the Section 244 threshold and are not arbitrable
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
A shareholders' agreement is a contract. Its parties are the shareholders who sign it and, in most Indian transactions, the company as well, so that the company is bound to act on the clauses that need its cooperation: registering or refusing a transfer, convening the board in a particular way, supplying information. It is governed by the Indian Contract Act 1872, which means it needs free consent, lawful consideration and a lawful object (Section 10), and it is enforced like any other contract: by damages under Section 73, by injunction or by specific performance under the Specific Relief Act 1963.
The Articles of Association are different in kind. They are a public document registered with the Registrar of Companies, binding on the company and every member under Section 10 of the Companies Act 2013 as if each had signed them, and alterable by a special resolution of the members under Section 14. A shareholder who joins later is bound by the Articles automatically; the same person is bound by the SHA only on signing it or a deed of adherence. The two documents therefore do different work: the SHA records the bargain, and the Articles give that bargain force inside the company.
| Point | Shareholders' agreement | Articles of Association |
|---|---|---|
| Legal nature | Private contract under the Indian Contract Act 1872 | Constitutional document of the company under Sections 5 and 10 of the Companies Act 2013 |
| Who is bound | Only the signatories, and the company if it signs | The company and every present and future member |
| Public record | Not filed; confidential between the parties | Filed with the Registrar; open to inspection on the MCA portal |
| How it changes | By the consent the agreement itself requires, usually every party or a named majority | Special resolution under Section 14, filed in Form MGT-14; entrenched clauses need the stricter procedure the Articles state under Section 5(3) |
| Content limits | Anything lawful between the parties, subject to the Companies Act and FEMA | Nothing repugnant to the Act (Section 6); Table F of Schedule I is the default model for a company limited by shares |
| Effect on a transfer | A breach gives a claim against the party in breach | A transfer in breach of the Articles can be refused by the company under Section 58(1) |
- Capital and shareholding. The cap table at signing, classes of shares, the ESOP pool and the fully diluted basis on which every percentage is measured.
- Transfer of shares. Lock-in, right of first refusal or first offer, tag-along, drag-along and the treatment of permitted transfers to affiliates and family members.
- New issues. Pre-emptive rights on fresh issues and anti-dilution protection for an investor who paid a higher price than a later round.
- Governance. Board size and composition, nominee and observer seats, quorum, reserved matters needing an affirmative vote, and information rights.
- Founders. Vesting of founder shares, good leaver and bad leaver outcomes, commitment of time and non-compete undertakings.
- Exit. IPO obligations, buy-back, put and call options, drag-along thresholds and liquidation preference.
- Protection. Representations and warranties, indemnities, confidentiality and conditions subsequent to the investment.
- Mechanics. Term and termination, deed of adherence for new shareholders, amendment, governing law, dispute resolution and notices.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
In V.B. Rangaraj v. V.B. Gopalakrishnan (1992) the Supreme Court held that a restriction on the transfer of shares agreed privately among the shareholders of a private company, but not written into the Articles, did not bind the company or the shareholders in their capacity as members; the transfer made in breach of the family arrangement stood. In Vodafone International Holdings v. Union of India (2012) the Court observed that shareholders may enter into any agreement in the best interest of the company, and that its terms are enforceable between them so long as they are not contrary to the Articles or to the Act. The Delhi High Court applied the same logic in World Phone India v. WPI Group (2013), declining to enforce an affirmative vote right that appeared in the SHA but not in the Articles.
The statute now supports both halves of that position. Section 2(68) requires a private company's Articles to restrict the transfer of its shares, so transfer clauses belong there by design. The proviso to Section 58(2) states that a contract or arrangement between two or more persons in respect of the transfer of securities is enforceable as a contract, which settles that pre-emption, tag and drag clauses are not void merely because shares of a public company are otherwise freely transferable. Section 6 then sets the ceiling: any provision of an agreement or of the Articles that is repugnant to the Act is void to that extent. An SHA cannot, for example, take away the members' power to remove a director by ordinary resolution under Section 169 or dispense with a special resolution the Act requires.
Conforming and entrenching the Articles
The practical rule that follows is to amend the Articles so that every clause the investor relies on also appears there: by special resolution under Section 14, filed with the Registrar in Form MGT-14 with the altered Articles attached (Section 14(2) gives 15 days for the altered Articles and Section 117 gives 30 days for the resolution). Where the investor wants protection against a later majority, the clauses are entrenched under Section 5(3): the Articles then provide that those provisions can be altered only by a procedure more restrictive than a special resolution, such as the written consent of the investor. Entrenchment is added to existing Articles by agreement of all the members of a private company and by special resolution in a public company (Section 5(4)), and the Registrar is notified in the form Rule 10 of the Companies (Incorporation) Rules 2014 prescribes (Section 5(5)). For securities of public companies the SEBI notification of 3 October 2013 under the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act 1956 recognises pre-emption, tag-along, drag-along and option clauses in shareholders' agreements as valid contracts.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
| Clause | What it does | Points the drafting settles |
|---|---|---|
| Lock-in | Bars founders, and at times investors, from transferring for a stated period or until an event such as an IPO. | Permitted transfers to affiliates and family, treatment of pledges, and the FEMA one-year lock-in where a non-resident holds an option. |
| Right of first refusal (ROFR) | A holder who has a third-party offer must first offer the shares to the other parties at the same price and terms. | The offer period, whether the right is pro rata or in priority, and what happens to the unaccepted balance. |
| Right of first offer (ROFO) | The holder names a price to the other parties before approaching outsiders; a third-party sale must then be at no lower price. | Faster for the seller than a ROFR because no outside bid is needed first; the window for the outside sale is fixed in days. |
| Tag-along (co-sale) | When a majority holder or founder sells, the other holders may sell a proportionate part of their shares to the buyer on the same terms. | Who holds the right, full or pro rata tag, and whether a change of control triggers a full tag. |
| Drag-along | Holders above a threshold who accept an offer can compel the rest to sell on identical terms. | The threshold, a minimum price or return, the period after which it applies, and a power of attorney so that the dragged holders' transfer forms can be signed. |
| Pre-emptive rights | Fresh shares are offered to existing holders in proportion before anyone else; Section 62(1)(a) does this by default for a rights issue. | Whether the right survives a preferential allotment under Section 62(1)(c), and carve-outs for the ESOP pool and the conversion of instruments. |
| Anti-dilution | Protects an investor if a later round is priced below the investor's price, by adjusting the conversion terms of the investor's instrument. | Full ratchet versus broad-based weighted average; Section 53 bars an issue at a discount to face value, so the adjustment works through conversion terms or additional shares at par. |
Mechanically every transfer still passes through Section 56: an instrument of transfer in Form SH-4, stamped, executed by both sides and delivered to the company within 60 days of execution, after which the company issues the certificate within one month. A private company whose Articles contain the restriction may refuse to register a transfer that breaches it, sending notice of the refusal within 30 days (Section 58(1)); the transferee may appeal to the Tribunal within 30 days of that notice (Section 58(3)). Since 1 July 2020 the Indian Stamp Act 1899, as amended by the Finance Act 2019, fixes the duty on a transfer of shares at 0.015% of the consideration and on an issue of shares at 0.005%, in place of the earlier state rates for these instruments.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
- Capital. Any issue, buy-back, reduction or reclassification of shares, and any change to the ESOP pool.
- Charter. Amendment of the Memorandum or Articles, change of name, of the state of the registered office or of the financial year.
- Business. Entering a new line of business, closing one, or incorporating or disposing of a subsidiary.
- Money. Borrowing, guarantees or security above an agreed limit; capital expenditure or acquisitions above a threshold; approval of the annual budget.
- People. Appointment, removal or remuneration of key managerial personnel and founders; adoption or amendment of an ESOP scheme.
- Related parties. Any transaction with a founder, director or their relatives, beyond the approvals Section 188 already requires.
- Exit and insolvency. An IPO, merger, sale of the business or a material part of it, voluntary winding up or an application under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016.
- Litigation and auditors. Commencing or settling material litigation; a change of the statutory auditor appointed under Section 139.
Reserved matters are enforced through the voting machinery. The Articles can require the affirmative vote of the investor's nominee director for a board decision, and the vote of the investor's class of shares for a members' decision, provided the result does not dispense with a majority the Act itself demands. Board seats follow Section 149 (at least two directors in a private company and three in a public company, up to 15 without a special resolution) and Section 152 on appointment by the members; a director nominated under an agreement is recognised by Section 161(3), subject to the Articles. The nominee's duties under Section 166 run to the company and its stakeholders, not to the nominating investor, and Section 166(4) bars the director from any undue gain, so an SHA that instructs the nominee how to vote is read as a right of the investor, not an obligation of the director. Quorum clauses commonly require the nominee's presence for a valid meeting, with an adjourned-meeting fallback so that the clause cannot be used to paralyse the company.
Information rights fill a gap in the statute. A member is entitled to the financial statements at least 21 days before the annual general meeting (Section 136) and to inspect the statutory registers (Section 94), but not to the books of account, which Section 128(3) opens to directors only. An SHA therefore specifies monthly management accounts, annual budgets, audited statements within a fixed time after the year end, and inspection and audit rights. Deadlock clauses complete the control package: escalation to named individuals, mediation, a casting vote for the chair on non-reserved items, a buy-sell (shotgun) mechanism under which one side names a price at which it will either buy or sell, and, as the end of the road, a petition to the Tribunal for winding up on the just and equitable ground in Section 271(e).
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
| Route | How the clause works | Statutory constraints |
|---|---|---|
| Initial public offering | A qualified IPO within a stated period, with conversion of preference shares before listing. | SEBI (Issue of Capital and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations 2018, including the promoter lock-in they prescribe; the company must be a public company before the offer. |
| Sale to a third party | Through the ROFR, ROFO, tag-along and drag-along clauses described above. | Section 56 transfer formalities; Section 58 refusal rights; FEMA pricing where either side is a non-resident; stamp duty of 0.015% on the transfer. |
| Buy-back by the company | The company purchases the investor's shares out of free reserves, the securities premium account or the proceeds of a fresh issue of a different kind of security. | Section 68: up to 10% of paid-up equity and free reserves by board resolution and up to 25% by special resolution; debt after the buy-back not more than twice the capital and free reserves; all shares fully paid; no second offer within one year; completion within one year of the resolution. |
| Put and call options | A put lets the investor require the founders or the company to buy; a call lets the founders or the company require the investor to sell, at a formula price. | Valid as contracts (Section 58(2) proviso; SEBI notification of 3 October 2013). For a non-resident holder: a one-year lock-in, exit at a price not above fair value and no assured return (NDI Rules 2019). A company can buy its own shares only under Section 68 (Section 67). |
| Founder buy-out | The founders buy the investor out at an agreed valuation or formula. | FEMA pricing caps the price a resident pays a non-resident at fair value; financial assistance from the company for the purchase is restricted by Section 67, with a conditional exemption for private companies under the notification of 5 June 2015. |
| Liquidation preference | On a liquidation, or a deemed liquidation such as a sale of the company, the investor receives its investment (or a multiple) before the equity holders share the rest; participating or non-participating. | Carried by preference shares issued under Section 43 and Rule 9 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules 2014, whose terms fix priority on repayment of capital. In a liquidation under the Code, Section 53 ranks preference shareholders above equity and equity last; a deemed liquidation event is contractual only. |
| Winding up | Voluntary liquidation where the company is solvent, or a petition on the just and equitable ground. | Section 59, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016; Section 271(e), Companies Act 2013. |
FEMA limits on a foreign investor's rights
Where any party is a person resident outside India, the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-debt Instruments) Rules 2019 overlay the SHA. The issue price to a non-resident cannot be below, and the exit price paid by a resident cannot be above, the fair value worked out under an internationally accepted pricing methodology and certified by a SEBI-registered merchant banker or another valuer Rule 21 names. An equity instrument may carry an optionality clause only with a lock-in of one year (or the longer sectoral period) and without any right to exit at an assured price. Investment from an entity of a country sharing a land border with India needs prior Government approval (Rule 6, after Press Note 3 of 2020). The issue is reported in Form FC-GPR within 30 days of allotment and a transfer between a resident and a non-resident in Form FC-TRS within 60 days, and Rule 9(6) allows up to 25% of the consideration on a transfer to be deferred for up to 18 months. The sectoral caps and conditions in Schedule I apply to every right the agreement confers.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
Founder vesting treats shares already issued as earned over time, typically four years with a one-year cliff, with acceleration on an acquisition or on termination without cause. Because a company cannot buy back its own shares outside Section 68, unvested shares on a founder's departure are dealt with by a call option in favour of the continuing founders or an employee welfare trust, or by a transfer at the agreed leaver price; a cancellation would need a reduction of capital confirmed by the Tribunal under Section 66. The leaver price is where good leaver and bad leaver matter: a good leaver (death, disability, termination without cause) usually keeps vested shares and sells unvested shares at fair value, while a bad leaver (resignation within the period, breach, termination for cause) sells at the lower of cost and fair value. Where the founder is a non-resident, the FEMA pricing rules override any formula that would pay more than fair value.
Non-compete clauses meet Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act 1872, which makes any agreement in restraint of a lawful profession, trade or business void to that extent, with a single statutory exception for the seller of goodwill, who may agree not to compete within specified local limits while the buyer carries on the business. Courts have upheld negative covenants that operate while the relationship subsists (Niranjan Shankar Golikari v. Century Spinning, 1967; Gujarat Bottling v. Coca-Cola, 1995) and struck down covenants that bite after it ends (Percept D'Mark v. Zaheer Khan, 2006). A founder non-compete is therefore drafted to run while the founder holds shares or office, with the post-exit restraint confined to confidentiality, non-solicitation and, where founders sell goodwill as part of an acquisition, the Section 27 exception.
The ESOP pool
Investors require an option pool to be created before their round so that its dilution falls on the founders. The pool is created under Section 62(1)(b) and Rule 12 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules 2014 by special resolution, which a private company may pass as an ordinary resolution under the exemption notification of 5 June 2015. Promoters, and directors who hold more than 10% of the equity directly or through relatives, are ineligible for options, except in a start-up recognised by DPIIT for ten years from incorporation. The SHA records the pool size on a fully diluted basis and the approvals needed to enlarge it.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
| Document | What it covers | Binding effect |
|---|---|---|
| Term sheet | Valuation, amount, instrument, the main rights (board seat, reserved matters, liquidation preference, anti-dilution), exclusivity and timetable. | Non-binding on the commercial terms; binding on confidentiality, exclusivity, costs and governing law where it says so. |
| Share subscription agreement (SSA) | The investment itself: number and price of shares, conditions precedent, use of funds, representations and warranties about the company, indemnities and closing mechanics. | Binding; performed at closing and then largely spent, except the warranties and indemnities, which survive for the period stated. |
| Shareholders' agreement (SHA) | The continuing relationship: transfers, governance, information, founders, exits and disputes. | Binding between the parties for its term; binding on the company through the conforming Articles. |
| Restated Articles of Association | The SHA terms rewritten as Articles and adopted by special resolution. | Binding on the company and every member under Section 10; filed in Form MGT-14. |
Agree the term sheet
The parties fix valuation, instrument and headline rights, with a cap table on a fully diluted basis so that every percentage in the later documents has one meaning.
Run diligence and clean the record
The investor reviews the charter documents, share capital history, filings and contracts; defects found now (unfiled resolutions, missing share certificates, unstamped transfers) are cured before signing.
Draft the SSA, SHA and Articles together
The three documents are drafted in parallel so that every SHA right has a matching Article and nothing conflicts with the Companies Act (Section 6) or, for a non-resident, the NDI Rules 2019.
Take the corporate approvals
Board approval of the documents and the issue; members' special resolutions to alter the Articles (Section 14), to authorise the preferential allotment under Section 62(1)(c) with a registered valuer's report or the private placement under Section 42, and to create the ESOP pool where agreed.
Stamp and sign
The SHA and SSA are stamped as agreements under the stamp law of the state of execution before or at signing; an instrument not duly stamped is inadmissible in evidence under Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act 1899 until the duty and penalty are paid.
Satisfy the conditions and close
Money is received, shares are allotted, PAS-3 is filed (within 15 days of a private placement allotment under Section 42(8), otherwise within 30 days), share certificates are issued within two months of allotment (Section 56(4)) and, for a non-resident investor, Form FC-GPR is filed within 30 days.
File and record
MGT-14 with the altered Articles within the Section 14 and Section 117 periods, notice of any entrenchment, entries in the register of members under Section 88, significant beneficial ownership declarations under Section 90 where an investor structure triggers them, and a deed of adherence from every later shareholder.
The two usual failures
An SHA that was never carried into the Articles, and an SHA that was never stamped. The first leaves the investor with a claim in damages against the founders but no right the company must honour; the second leaves the document unusable in court until the duty and penalty are paid. Both surface in the next due diligence.
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
An arbitration clause is an agreement in writing under Section 7 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996. It should name the seat (which fixes the supervising court), the number of arbitrators, the institution or appointment mechanism (Section 11), the language and the governing law of the SHA. A court before which a party sues on a matter covered by the clause refers the parties to arbitration under Section 8; interim relief, such as an order restraining a transfer or an allotment, is available from the court under Section 9 and from the tribunal under Section 17. Where a party is foreign the parties often choose a foreign seat, and the resulting award is enforced in India under Part II of the Act.
What arbitration cannot decide is a petition for oppression and mismanagement. Under Section 241, members who meet the Section 244 threshold (not less than one-tenth of the issued share capital, or not less than 100 members or one-tenth of the members, whichever is less; one-fifth of the members in a company without share capital; with power in the Tribunal to waive the requirement) may complain to the National Company Law Tribunal of conduct prejudicial to them, to the company or to the public interest, and Section 430 bars civil courts from matters the Tribunal is empowered to decide. Courts treat such petitions as non-arbitrable because the reliefs under Section 242 operate against the company and third parties (Rakesh Malhotra v. Rajinder Malhotra, Bombay High Court, 2014), although a petition that merely dresses up a contractual claim is sent back to arbitration, and the Supreme Court's four-fold test in Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading (2020) now frames the question. An SHA therefore states that nothing in the arbitration clause restricts a party's statutory remedies before the Tribunal.
Damages
Compensation for loss caused by the breach under Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act 1872, including liquidated damages under Section 74 where the agreement fixes a reasonable sum.
Injunction
An order restraining a transfer, allotment or vote in breach of a negative covenant under Sections 38 to 42 of the Specific Relief Act 1963; the usual interim relief under Section 9 of the arbitration statute.
Specific performance
Since the 2018 amendment of the Specific Relief Act, specific performance of a contract is the default remedy rather than a discretion, subject to the exclusions in Section 14; a drag-along or a put option can be enforced in kind.
Tribunal relief
Under Section 242 the Tribunal may regulate the company's affairs, order a buy-out of any member, set aside transfers and remove directors; the order binds the company whatever the SHA says.
Rectification
Section 59 lets a person aggrieved by a wrongful entry or omission in the register of members apply to the Tribunal, the remedy where a transfer in breach of the Articles was registered.
Winding up
The just and equitable ground in Section 271(e) remains the remedy of last resort for a deadlocked company run as a quasi-partnership.
Related topics
- Right of first refusal (ROFR)
- The right of existing shareholders to buy shares a holder proposes to sell to an outsider, at the price and on the terms the outsider offered, before the sale proceeds.
- Right of first offer (ROFO)
- The obligation of a selling holder to offer the shares to the other parties at a price the seller names before approaching outsiders, who must then pay at least that price.
- Tag-along right
- The right of a minority holder to join a sale by the majority and sell a proportionate part of its shares to the same buyer on the same terms.
- Drag-along right
- The right of holders above a stated threshold who accept an offer to compel the remaining holders to sell on identical terms, enforced through the Articles and a power of attorney.
- Reserved matters
- Decisions of the board or the members that cannot be taken without the affirmative vote or written consent of a named shareholder or class, carried into the Articles so that the company is bound.
- Anti-dilution protection
- An adjustment to the conversion price of an investor's instrument when a later round is priced lower, by full ratchet (to the new price) or weighted average (in proportion to the size of the new round).
- Liquidation preference
- The right of preference shareholders to receive their investment, or a multiple of it, before equity holders share the remaining proceeds of a liquidation or of a deemed liquidation such as a sale of the company.
- Deed of adherence
- A short deed by which a person acquiring shares agrees to be bound by the existing shareholders' agreement as if an original party; the SHA makes its signature a condition of any transfer or issue.
Related topics
Related topics
The statute, rules and portals the page relies on. Check them before acting: fees, forms and time limits change by notification.
- Companies Act, 2013, India Code
- Indian Contract Act, 1872 (Sections 10, 27, 73), India Code
- Indian Stamp Act, 1899 (Section 35), India Code
- Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, India Code
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (Section 53), India Code
- Reserve Bank of India: Master Direction on Foreign Investment in India
- Ministry of Corporate Affairs: Companies Act, 2013 and rules
